Welcome to Di Carlo’s Pizzeria of Westbury
Di Carlo’s Pizzeria of Westbury, located at 894 Old Country Rd, is a beloved eatery known for its authentic Italian flavors and warm family atmosphere. With a menu featuring delectable pizza slices, hearty soups, and mouthwatering pasta dishes, there's something for everyone. Signature offerings such as the Chicken Bacon Ranch and Lobster Ravioli showcase a delightful blend of ingredients. Customers rave about the friendly staff who create a welcoming vibe, making it a go-to spot for locals. From gooey cheese to perfectly baked breads, Di Carlo’s proves that quality and care shine through in every bite. An essential stop for pizza lovers!
-
894 Old Country Rd, Westbury, NY 11590, United States894 Old Country Rd, Westbury, NY 11590, United States Hotline: +1 516-338-4966
Welcome to Di Carlo’s Pizzeria of Westbury, a hidden gem nestled at 894 Old Country Rd, Westbury, NY. This family-owned pizzeria has established itself as a beloved favorite in the community, thanks to its warm atmosphere and dedication to authentic Italian cuisine. Just a quick call at +1 516-338-4966 will connect you to a culinary experience that feels like home.
From the moment you step inside, you’re greeted with a familiar smile. Di Carlo’s isn't just a place to grab a bite; it’s where families gather. Customers rave about the friendly service, recalling how the staff remembers their names and even inquires about their lives. It’s this personal touch that transforms a simple meal into cherished moments.
The menu here is a celebration of flavor, showcasing specialty pies that set Di Carlo’s apart from the rest. The Chicken Marsala Pie, laden with tender chicken and a rich Marsala wine sauce, is a must-try, while the Stuffed Meat Pie serves as a hearty and satisfying choice with its golden crust and savory filling. For those who adore a medley of flavors, the House Special combines sausage, meatballs, pepperoni, mushrooms, and more, resulting in an unforgettable taste experience.
Pastas at Di Carlo's aren’t merely sides; they are substantial dishes that showcase culinary expertise. With options like Penne Alla Vodka and Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken, each dish is crafted with quality ingredients, ensuring that every bite resonates with flavor. The Spaghetti with Garlic and Oil offers a simple yet robust option for those seeking comfort food with an Italian flair.
Catering? Look no further. Di Carlo’s provides ample options that leave guests raving at any gathering. Their Buffalo Wings and Chicken Fingers come highly recommended, perfect for sharing during celebrations or game-day parties. Just ask fellow patrons like Omar Cruz, who found their catered dishes to be nothing short of amazing!
In the bustling area of Long Island, it’s easy to find excellent pizza—but few deliver the genuine experience of Di Carlo’s. It’s not just about the food; it's about community, culture, and connection. With top-notch ingredients and dishes crafted with love, Di Carlo's is a testament to true Italian hospitality. Next time you’re searching for a slice or planning an event, remember Di Carlo’s Pizzeria of Westbury—a place where every meal feels like coming home.
Ever since we moved to Westbury we haven’t even tried another pizza place. Would def recommend DiCarlo’s. They’re so nice, they even know my son’s name when we come in, and say hello and ask him how school is going. Pizza is very good. Great spot.
Classic pizza shop. Great staff and service. Great vibes all around. This was a great spot to pick while visiting Long Island!
My new pizza spot! They catered our last gathering. food was amazing (chicken francese and penne a la vodka w gr. Chicken) my daughter and I love their wings! Thank you Carlos and the rest of the di carlo family!.
This was by far the best tasting authentic, Italian pizza!! My sons said, "the cheese was so goey & delicious !! The best pizza I've tasted in my 16yrs!!" I had the garlic knots & I too was soo impressed. I really appreciated the warm & family vibes from those that helped me with my order. I'll definitely be back & I recommend you go too!!
food was fresh didnt take long and the employees were wonderful and kind!
This is one of the best pizza joint in the area. I asked for my pizza to be crispy and well done. Carlos, he made sure that my pizza was crisped to the perfection. . They listen to their customers and tailor the food accordingly. . Customer service was Seven Star level. I would come back here and get pizza again. . Kelly, at the front desk is a super friendly person. . Cleanliness 10 out of 10 Friendless 10 out of 10 The quality of the food 10 out of 10 The speed of the service 10 out of 10 Over all experience 10 out of 10
So...freaking...FULL. I got an order of Pasta Alfredo, a Grandma Slice, and a slice of pepperoni for pick up to bring back to the hotel. All, absolutely delicious. The Alfredo was enough for two people, easily. Rich, buttery without being oily. Perfect ratio of sauce to pasta. Being from Louisiana, this was my first Grandma Slice. I'm hooked, and now I'm getting a Gma Slice anytime I see it on the menu just to compare. It was delicious. The pepperoni slice is everything I expect NY pizza to be. Piping hot, sauce and crust was perfect. Best of all, the welcoming smiles of the staff and the friendly waves as I left makes me regret I didn't done in. I highly recommend this spot. I shall return!
An amazing experience- they can handle large orders, and the service went above and beyond!! It was a frigid day, but the delivery was impeccable. Pizzas were still steaming hot. Came with free garlic knots which was very much appreciated. People were seriously impressed with the specialty pizzas (had veggie, house special, margarita, grandma, chicken Caesar, and breaded eggplant)— I was asked to share the place. Good thing the delivery man left some menu pamphlets. 5/5 recommend